Skip to content
Urban Watch Scope

Can Hiromu Arakawa of Fullmetal Alchemist Strike Anime Gold Twice?

Hiromu Arakawa's FMA is widely regarded as a definitive entry-point series. Taking place in the martial state of Amestris, the narrative chronicles alchemist brothers Edward and Alphonse during their desperate search for the mythical artifact. Their mission ultimately alters the fate of the world. The manga spawned adaptations into two distinct anime shows: the 2003 anime, a character-driven slow-burn that diverged from the source material, and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, which faithfully recreates Arakawa’s lush thematic framework and worldbuilding.

Visual: Animation Studio

This award-winning manga sets a towering standard for dark-fantasy shōnen thanks to its mature handling of concepts like the tussle between science and faith. Consequently, anything Arakawa created following her masterpiece was inevitably doomed to live in its shadow, such as her ongoing manga, Daemons of the Shadow Realm.

The highly anticipated first episode of the new series is set to premiere on April 4th on the streaming service. The studio, behind both Fullmetal Alchemist adaptations, is bringing this mysterious world to life with director Masahiro Andō at the helm. Based on the premiere episode, the anime has the potential to become a major hit of the season thanks to its compelling cast and an impactful twist. However, while the fresh anime is full of charm and intrigue, the enduring shadow of Fullmetal Alchemist could continue to loom large.

Will this new venture equal the acclaim of its predecessor, or go beyond it? Here’s what you need to know.

Note: The following includes plot details for the Daemons of the Shadow Realm manga.

What is Daemons About?

Image: Bones Film

Readers of the manga's opening can attest to its gripping supernatural premise. The story opens with the birth of siblings Yuru and Asa, who are tied to a mystical prophecy. After 16 years, we see Yuru idling in the woods of Higashi Village alongside his friend Danji. He meets up with his twin sister Asa, who communicates with her brother from within a sealed room, setting an uneasy tone.

The first episode faithfully recreates these expository beats while leading to a climactic tragedy. When Yuru and Danji hear a fluttering sound, the quaint village is suddenly surrounded by violent outsiders. A bloody massacre unfolds, leaving Yuru terrified for his sister’s safety. The horrific nature of the assault is captured with chaotic camera work and tight shots of Yuru’s tormented face.

Image: Animation Studio

This drastic tonal shift introduces the “shadow realm” itself. We quickly learn that Yuru and Asa are fated to control supernatural creatures named demons that can manifest in the real world. Many mysteries remain by the time the credits roll, suggesting a promising opening chapter that manages to hooking the audience.

This premiere is merely a taste into the broader universe of the ongoing manga. It would be too early to say whether the adaptation will succeed in translating this new dark fantasy into a kinetic anime series, but its debut certainly has a challenge ahead.

How Similar Are Daemons of the Shadow Realm and Fullmetal Alchemist?

Image: Animation Studio

The creator's distinctive visual style, known for blonde-haired protagonists with expressive faces, culminates in Yuru. The protagonist looks like characters from FMA, and embraces a comparable sense of honor that Edward embodies.

That said, Yuru lives in a wholly distinct setting. Raised in a isolated village with few comforts, a place of trade essentials. He remains unaware about the world outside Higashi Village, casting him as a naive hero. While this is an endearing quality, Daemons of the Shadow Realm could be perceived as seeming “bland” next to the intricate depth of the Elric brothers.

Parts of the premiere contain uneven art which may seem fairly distracting, but the rest is cohesive enough to amount to an engaging start. Maybe the anime can avoid high comparisons tied to Fullmetal Alchemist by offering a series that feels like a breath of fresh air. Viewers may find that its approachable style will be a strength and captivate audiences with its mysterious shade of dark fantasy.


Daemons of the Shadow Realm premieres on April 4th on Crunchyroll.

By

Abigail Richard

Urban culture enthusiast and freelance journalist covering city life and trends.

Urban Watch Scope

Type to search articles.